





Category Archives for Uncategorized
Report on Tony Blair's descent into madness
Nahui Olin of Echo Park (L.A. Calif)
‘Our store’s name is “Nahui Ohlin” which in nahuatl means: Four Movement. We decided to call it this because we felt we had to represent our ancestral wisdom and history. You see, four is a sacred number which in itself expresses movement. The four Directions, Four Elements, Four Major nations on this continent, The Inka, Maya, Mexikah, and Kahokia. There are also four seasons, and four stages of human life: Infant, adolescent, adult, and elder. All part of movement. And this store and idea, is the re-birth of an Indigenous movement. We try to cover the different perspectives of our culture. We have Northern Indigenous literature, and history. Also crafts from Mexikoh, which represent the day of the Dead. We have Alpaka hats from Ecuador, and our most popular item: T-shirts. Revolutionary, Indigenous, Traditional, Political, Payasadas, and just plain garras Firmes. We have underground Hip Hop, musica folclorica, Musica de protesta, and Speeches by Messengers of Justice. Books of Revolutionary movements in Centro America, and Mexikoh. Jewelry, incense, old Rustic images of Tonantzin, and hand made hand bags. We even have “Mexican Lucha Libre” masks.
We decided to open up a shop in Echo Park because of the lack of cultural representation in this part of the city. In fact, we felt like after the “Chavez Ravine” incident in the late 50’s la raza in this area has been kept silenced and passive. Hardly anyone knows that the team they support and defend out at the stadium, forcibly evicted Mexicanos out of their homes to make way for progress. The Dodger clan is now trying to heal those wounds by exhibiting Raza on their billboards as cheering fans. Reflecting us as passive supporters of “La Dodgerization”.
We defiantly reject the Gentrification that is also taking place here in Echo Park. La Raza, once again is being displaced and ejected out of Echo Park. History repeats itself. But, nosotros on the other hand are counterattacking it. We “Degentrificate” by moving in. We are here to represent la Raza and our grandiose Cultura. ‘
Well past time to pay up.
Is U.S. ready to settle with Native Americans?
Dispute over land royalties and Indian Trust Fund may end this fall
By Joel Seidman
NBC News
Updated: 12:41 a.m. PT Aug 2, 2006
WASHINGTON – For Elouise Cobell, a Native American landowner who launched a class-action lawsuit in 1996 against the U.S. government, there may be reason to be optimistic.
The battle over the Indian Trust Fund has been going on unofficially for more than a century, encompassing Indian lands dating back to 1887. Wednesday, the chairman of the Senate Indian Affairs Committee said a settlement is within reach.
Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., had two high level visitors to his Capitol Hill office Tuesday morning. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales and Interior Secretary Dirk Kempthorne came to talk with McCain about trying to settle the long-term dispute.
The Interior Department manages Cobell’s property and that of about 500,000 other Native Americans, leasing the oil, timber, mining and grazing rights, and collecting the money in trusts and distributing it to the owners. Cobell contends the government owes Indians more than $50 billion.
Gonzales and Kempthorne spoke with McCain and Sen. Byron Dorgan, D-N.D., the ranking Democrat on the committee, a day before both were to offer a bill that would have suggested a settlement of close to $8 billion to compensate Indian land owners.
The bill never made it. McCain says he was willing to listen to what the government had to offer and hold off with legislation until the Senate comes back from its month-long summer recess in September. “I won’t agree to anything unless Cobell feels it’s OK,” McCain told NBC News.
In a letter to McCain, Interior Secretary Kempthorne writes: “There is both an atmosphere and positive attitude in the Administration to find a settlement solution. I believe we have a historic opportunity to embrace constructive solutions to long-standing trust management concerns held by generations of Indians.”
Cobell feels this is a positive move, her spokesman Bill McAllister said, though she is disappointed the administration “does not seem ready to resolve this quickly.” Last week, when McCain was drafting his bill, she said, “It would be foolish to ignore political realities while our people continue to go without the basic staples of life. That is why I and the other representative plaintiffs are considering this settlement offer.” But Cobell reiterated, “I have been quoted as saying that an $8 billion dollar settlement amount for the historical accounting claims of 500,000 individual Indian trust beneficiaries is ‘equitable.’ That is not what I said. That is not what I believe.”
For the past 10 years the court battle has been a messy, protracted affair. Cobell has won a series of victories. U.S. District Judge Royce Lamberth held Interior Secretaries Bruce Babbitt and Gale Norton in contempt and ordered the Interior Department to disconnect its computers from the Internet to secure Indian trust data.
Indian trust documents were once scattered throughout all 50 states, some in federal facilities, others jammed into barns, attics and even storage sheds. Nobody was even sure what was out there. Lamberth ordered the Interior Department to collect boxes full of Indian records from across the country and have them trucked to Lenexa, Kansas. National Archives workers then file the documents in boxes. So far, there are more than 145,000 boxes there, 300 million documents with new shipments arriving weekly.
But those victories ended last month when the government won a major battle by removing Judge Lamberth from the case, who had repeatedly vowed to expose the Department of Interior, whose “spite,” he said, has led it to turn its “wrath” on trust beneficiaries and engage in “willful misconduct,” “iniquities,” “scandals,” “dirty tricks” and “outright villainy.”
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, siding with the government, removed Lamberth. The appeals court found that Lamberth had lost his objectivity. “We conclude, reluctantly, that this is one of those rare cases in which reassignment is necessary,” the judges wrote. The court ordered the case reassigned to another judge. The appeals court said, “Our ruling today presents an opportunity for a fresh start … We expect both parties to work with the new judge to resolve this case expeditiously and fairly.”
Repeated federal reports have exposed corruption and mismanagement in the Indian Trust system — no one has ever attempted a complete accounting. Cobell, a Blackfoot Indian from Montana, asked the court to find out what no one else could. She asked, “How much money has the government earned on tribal lands from leases for oil and mineral and timber and grazing?” By law, that money is meant for the Indian Trust Fund.
But the appeals court concluded that Lamberth went too far, “on several occasions the district court or its appointees exceeded the role of impartial arbiter.” The Court wrote that Lamberth believed that racism at Interior continued, quoting a Lamberth ruling in which he states the department is “a dinosaur — the morally and culturally oblivious hand-me-down of a disgracefully racist and imperialist government that should have been buried a century ago, the last pathetic outpost of the indifference and anglo-centrism we thought we had left behind.”
Recognizing the harm done to Indian tribes by the mismanagement of the trust fund, the appeals court wrote: “This case serves as an appalling reminder of the evils that result when large numbers of the politically powerless are placed at the mercy of institutions engendered and controlled by a politically powerful few. It reminds us that even today our great democratic enterprise remains unfinished. And it reminds us, finally, that the terrible power of government, and the frailty of the restraints on the exercise of that power, are never fully revealed until government turns against the people.”
The appeals court also issued a stern warning to the government, that it has, “an obligation to rise above its deplorable record and help fashion an effective remedy.”
In their letter Tuesday to McCain, Interior Secretary Kempthorne writes: “If we can define a legislative settlement consistent with our collective goals, I believe, together, we can determine what financial consideration and level of funding for improved beneficiary services would be provided to Indian Country.”
McCain warned that establishing a monetary settlement won’t be easy. “The OMB will be involved,” he said. The Office of Management and Budget, McCain intimated, was not happy even with the $8 billion number he had suggested in his legislative draft.
The chief judge of the District Court, Thomas Hogan, has 30 days from the appeals court ruling to appoint a new judge to hear this case.
McCain said he didn’t think that Congress or the Indian land-owners could wait another 10 years mired in litigation to resolve the issue.
'Everybody Was Dead Around Me'
July 31, 2006 Los Angeles Times
WARFARE IN THE MIDDLE EAST
By Megan K. Stack
Times Staff Writer
QANA, Lebanon — Hour after gruesome hour, the bodies came to light Sunday. Corpses with limbs snapped into unnatural poses. Women with arms frozen upward, as if they died grasping at the sky. Children with blue faces, their mouths packed with dirt.
The two families had moved into a basement of a half-built home because they hoped it would protect them from Israeli attack; but by sunrise, they were dead.
As many as 56 people were suffocated or crushed to death by an Israeli airstrike on the home in this southern Lebanese town. Many of them were children.
The few who survived sat in hospital cots with haunted eyes Sunday. They spoke of the long hours trapped beneath heavy heaps of rubble and recalled the dying groans of their loved ones that faded through the night to silence.
“When I woke up, I started screaming, and I kept screaming for two hours,” Heyam Hasham said. Her fingernails were broken and caked with earth. She couldn’t remember how they got that way. “I thought I’d die because everybody was dead around me.”
Blinking dazedly in her hospital bed, Hasham described the last night in the house: The families tucked into a dinner of potatoes and onions at 4 p.m., then gathered around their portable radio by candlelight and listened to a speech by Hezbollah leader Sheik Hassan Nasrallah.
“When we heard him,” Hasham said, “we were praying to stop the war.”
Israel expressed “deep sorrow” for Sunday’s attack but said Hezbollah rockets were being fired from the area. Government officials also pointed out that civilians had been warned to leave southern Lebanon.
“Liars! Liars!” cried Zeinab Ahmed Shalhoub from her hospital bed. “Every time there is a massacre they lie and make up an excuse.”
Across the hospital room, her sister, Hala Ahmed Shalhoub, nodded silently. The woman’s face was wan, her skin papery and eyes hollow. She gripped her bedsheet tight to her chin and told her story in the flat voice of a person shocked beyond emotion.
Bombs had rattled the valleys when she stretched out on a mattress with her two girls. She had to sleep, she decided, missiles or no missiles. As she drifted off, the 24-year-old mother rolled away from 18-month-old Rokaya and 3 1/2 -year-old Fatima. She felt their warm breath on her neck.
When the bomb crashed into the house, she thought it had hit a neighbor’s place. Then she realized her mouth was full of dust, and she couldn’t move under a heavy crush of rubble. Her daughters whimpered in her ear, but she couldn’t reach back to touch them.
Shalhoub doesn’t know how much time went by as she lay facedown in the dirt, listening as death overtook her only children.
“I heard my baby girl moaning in my ear,” she said, holding one listless hand alongside her ear to show where the child had lain.
“They were all covered with the dust, and they died,” Shalhoub said. “I couldn’t scream.”
It was her sister who finally saved her. The younger woman extricated herself from the broken house, hauled herself over to her sister and pulled her to safety.
By that time, Shalhoub had convinced herself that her 18-month-old baby was still alive. The child was still warm; she was sure of it.
“Get my baby,” she urged her sister.
She was hallucinating. The tiny corpse was stone cold.
Shalhoub said that she had been excited — her older daughter would soon begin school. Her eyes filled with tears at the thought. But a few beats later, she insisted that her children were martyrs and said she was glad for their deaths.
“These children, they are going to heaven,” she said. “The people who did this massacre are going to hell.”
Aside from her children, Shalhoub lost both her parents, two brothers and a sister in the attack. Her husband, along with some of the other men in the family, was in a neighboring basement at the time of the attack, she said.
A pale, bespectacled nurse named Chadi Hassan stood listening from the door in his white coat.
“Every day is a disaster here,” he muttered as he turned back to the corridor. “America is sending the best of its bombs to Israel.”
The families had come to live here on the outskirts of Qana because they were afraid to stay in their one-story houses, survivors and neighbors said. Like many families, they did not want to leave, despite the warnings to flee; they thought the war would not last long.
They got by in the basement without electricity. The mattresses were packed so tightly they had to stack them to make room to heat food on their butane cooker.
The house, owned by two grown brothers, was a dream home that hadn’t been finished. Every time one of the brothers earned a little extra money, he would put it toward the house. The pair had been working on it for four years.
Despite the Israeli bombing campaign, the children had been whiling away the summer days playing on the rocky hillsides, neighbors and parents said. They rode bicycles down the slopes and played make-believe with their dolls. They scrambled around playing hide-and-seek and soccer.
“For sure, the drones must have recognized that there were children playing in the area,” said Mohsen Hashem, a 30-year-old relative.
“They couldn’t fight the resistance on the borderline, so they came here to fight civilians with their planes.”
When the bombing let up Sunday morning, Mohammed Ismael was one of the first to arrive. When the 38-year-old scrambled up the hill and saw what remained of the house, the silence filled him with dread. Everybody must have died, he thought.
“I shouted and screamed,” he said. “I started calling names, ‘Are you all right?’ And nobody answered…. I knew they were all dead.”
He saw a 7-year-old girl sprawled on the wreckage. He thought she was asleep — then he noticed that her eyes were open, and still. He scooped her body up in his arms and carried her out. That was the beginning of a daylong hunt for bodies.
“Let America know,” Ismael said, “that from now on, if a kid is 1 year old, we’ll teach him how to fight America and fight Israel.”
Hours after the explosion, dust clung to Ismael’s mustache and coated his ears. His skinny arms were wrapped across his chest; he looked small and sad.
Rescuers said they believed many of the victims had died slowly through the long night of bombs, their faces pinned to the dirt. The bombs had kept ambulances away until daybreak. Even then, a bomb fell a soccer-field’s length from the first vehicle to arrive.
An empty silence clasped the hills Sunday. The orchards were full of hard green olives. Summer-swollen pomegranates bent the branches of trees. White flowers spangled the tobacco plants, and harvested leaves had been hung to dry on wires around the shattered house.
But everything was broken. It looked as if some enormous beast had taken a swipe out of the hillside, leaving a tumble-down structure leaking chunks of cement and twisted rebar. Rescue workers disappeared into the darkness of the rubble and emerged carrying small bodies. They lined the corpses up on a dirt path and covered them with a sheet.
“This is the most horrible thing I’ve seen,” said Red Cross volunteer Mohammed Zaatar. “It’s small babies.
“You scratch in the earth — nothing, nothing, nothing,” Zaatar added. “You follow your senses. When you feel a body underground, something shakes you. It’s a life, it’s a man, it’s a woman.”
A page torn from a child’s coloring book lay tattered on the ground, scrawled over with strokes of sunny yellow and bright blue. A diaper was discarded. Ambulances were crammed with dead children.
The groan of passing jets echoed over the valley as men dug for bodies. Sometimes the rescuers paused and turned anxious faces to the sky. Most of the time, they paid no attention — too busy or too traumatized to care.
A lieutenant colonel in the Lebanese army huddled over a list of names trying to piece together a tally of the dead. Everybody was doing that — soldiers, neighbors, surviving family members and Red Cross volunteers. He shook his head and pulled slowly on his cigar.
“As a soldier, I know there are laws for war,” he said. “This is a mass execution.”
An old woman with a deeply furrowed face and a head scarf pinned beneath her chin stepped along a rocky path toward the gutted house. The grief came in pulses over her features, and as she neared the house the sorrow erupted.
“I want to see how they were killed,” she said. “I want to see for the memories.”
*
Times photographer Carolyn Cole contributed to this report.
JULY 28-SAN DIEGO, JULY 29-L.A.: DERRICK JENSEN LIVE IN S. CALIFORNIA.
Green is the new Red…the 1950s had their vast Communist conspiracy, Congressional hearings, blacklists, and red-baiting. Today, we have “Eco-Terrorists…” secret databases, Congressional hearings, indictments, grand juries, raids, surveillance, arrests, convictions, and potential life sentences.
On December 7th, 2005 federal and local law enforcement began the largest roundup of alleged environmental and animal liberation activists in American history. Over the next several months, the number of arrests, indictments, and subpoenas would mount in what the government called “Operation Backfire” and what activists would eventually term THE GREEN SCARE.
In the so-called “War Against Terrorism”…
…the terrorists aren’t the ones behind bars.
Join acclaimed activist and author, Derrick Jensen, for a night of dialogue, debate, controversy, and an exploration of the nature of injustice in a so-called civilized world.
Cost:
$10 sliding scale donation at the door
(generosity greatly appreciated)
No one turned away for lack of funds.
All proceeds to benefit non-cooperating victims of the Green Scare
* Government agents subject to a $975 surcharge*
Friday, July 28th… San Diego
7:00pm- 9:30pm
Che Café
At the UC San Diego campus, La Jolla, Calif., 92093
(Building 161 on the UCSD campus map)
Off I-5 / La Jolla Village Dr. / Gilman Dr.
Directions: http://checafe.ucsd.edu/directions.html
http://checafe.ucsd.edu/
Venue: (858) 534-2311
For map, please visit: http://checafe.ucsd.edu/map.html
Saturday, July 29th… Los Angeles
7:00pm- 9:30pm
Sandpaper Books
3706 N. Figueroa Street, Los Angeles, Calif., 90065
(Near Figueroa St. & W. Avenue 37 off the 110 Freeway)
For additional info:
Info [at] EcoPrisoners [dot] org
(323) 304-2211
DerrickJensen.org
EcoPrisoners.org
May a Katrina-scale "act of God" hit Pebble Beach this weekend.
From the July 28, 2006 Los Angeles Times
Media Mogul Summons the Powerful to Expound
By Sallie Hofmeister
Times Staff Writer
When 250 News Corp. executives gather this weekend for a management retreat at a posh California seaside resort, they’ll skip the typical team-building exercises that such confabs are known for. Why role-play when you can pick the brains of actual world leaders and rock stars?
Speakers at the Pebble Beach event will include such political powers as British Prime Minister Tony Blair, former President Clinton and Israeli Vice Premier Shimon Peres. Los Angeles Police Chief William J. Bratton will opine on remaking complex organizations, former Vice President Al Gore will riff on climate change, and U2’s Bono will deliver a keynote address titled “The Power of One.”
The singer is likely to focus on his poverty- and AIDS-related crusade, called One. But Bono could just as easily be referring to his host, Rupert Murdoch, the chairman of News Corp.
If there’s one man with the power to summon the powerful, mogul watchers agree, it’s Murdoch.
“It’s his unique persona and his global reach that puts him in a special category,” said Jeffrey Sonnenfeld of the Yale School of Management. “He is the fulfillment, although not ideologically, of what Ted Turner aspired to be, in terms of having influence not only culturally but socially. Unlike [Viacom Inc. Chairman] Sumner Redstone, Murdoch is interested in influence as much as affluence.”
Call it the Rupert effect. The 75-year-old media maverick personally invited many of the luminaries who will make the five-day retreat an unusually high-powered blend of politics and business. Not only did they say yes, but at least one — Clinton — waived his usual $100,000 speaking fee.
A five-page agenda obtained by The Times reveals what management experts and company insiders say is a testament to Murdoch’s unusual global vision and a product of his ownership of newspapers in Australia, New York and Britain, broadcast properties and cable channels such as Fox News and satellite TV services that reach every corner of the world.
“Murdoch has created a global media market by successfully operating in very different regulatory and political environments,” said Kathleen Hall Jamieson, director of the Annenberg Public Policy Center at the University of Pennsylvania. The retreat’s lineup of speakers, she said, “may tell you how he has learned about the broad base of business environments he operates in.”
News Corp. declined to discuss details of the program. According to the agenda, Murdoch will make some opening remarks Sunday evening before turning over the podium to Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, who in turn will introduce Blair.
Over the next several days, Peres will appear on a panel called “Islam and the West” and News Corp.’s Roger Ailes, who built Fox News, will introduce four high-ranking U.S. military officers who have served in Iraq. Sen. John McCain, the Arizona Republican and presidential hopeful, will talk about America’s political polarity, and Clinton will conduct a town-hall-style discussion as the gathering wraps up Thursday.
“It’s not your standard cookie-cutter management conference where you only talk about business,” News Corp. spokesman Andrew Butcher said. “The businesses we run give our people unique social responsibilities in their communities. The retreat is meant to provoke and broaden their perspectives so they return home more curious and informed about the world.”
What’s in it for the politicians? That’s simple, Jamieson said: “Media influence and the potential for political contributions.”
Murdoch, a staunch Republican, contributed $41,000 to federal political campaigns during the 2004 elections, and News Corp. President Peter Chernin, a Democrat, donated $53,000, according to the Center for Responsive Politics. News Corp.’s political action committee gave nearly $360,000 to House and Senate candidates in the 2003-04 elections, according to PoliticalMoneyLine.
News Corp. said politicians who currently hold office would not be paid for their participation. Jamieson said that paying them would have posed a potential conflict of interest given their influence on media regulation.
Company executives said Clinton waived his fee because of personal ties to the company; News Corp. Executive Vice President Gary Ginsberg was a lawyer in the Clinton White House. Also, despite his conservative leanings, Murdoch, who owns the New York Post, hosted a fundraiser last week for Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton (D.-N.Y.).
World politics will not be the only topic on the agenda. A.G. Lafley, chief executive of Procter & Gamble, will lecture on building brands. A panel called “Meet the MySpace Generation” is billed as a “live focus group” that will explore the attitudes and lifestyles of 20 students. General Manager Billy Beane of the Oakland A’s baseball team will talk about radical approaches to traditional business. And the LAPD’s Bratton will be joined on his panel about reforming institutions by former House Speaker Newt Gingrich and former Harvard University President Lawrence H. Summers.
The retreat will be a family reunion of sorts for Murdoch. His son James, who runs News Corp.’s BSkyB satellite service in Britain, will introduce some speakers. Other Murdoch children also will be on hand, including News Corp. director Lachlan Murdoch, who quit his management position with family-controlled News Corp. last summer amid conflicts with his father.
The retreat in Pebble Beach, just up the road from Murdoch’s Carmel ranch, is modeled after an exclusive annual summit for media, technology and financial moguls hosted by investment banking firm Allen & Co. in Sun Valley, Idaho.
Both events devote mornings to formal presentations and afternoons to hobnobbing outdoors. Allen & Co. shells out an estimated $10 million to treat its guests and their families to white-water rafting, fly fishing, golf, skating, skeet-shooting and yoga. In Pebble Beach, News Corp. executives will be able to choose from 20 activities, including golf, tennis and skydiving.
For News Corp., which is known for being tight-fisted, the retreat’s trappings are lavish. At Pebble Beach, one round of golf can cost $450, including a cart. Executive suites at the Inn at Spanish Bay, where some guests are staying, start at $995 a night.
Although the Allen & Co. conference is held annually, this year’s News Corp. summit is the first since 1998. A get-together planned for 2001 was never held because of the 9/11 terrorist attacks.
Sunday, July 30 in Brooklyn

How Missionaries Keep Fucking Up the Lives of Indigenous People
TV Review
‘P.O.V.’ on PBS: How Missionaries Spread the Word, and U.S. Capitalism
By VIRGINIA HEFFERNAN
Are evangelical missionaries good or bad? That’s the question in tonight’s PBS documentary, “The Tailenders.” The missionaries’ smugness and salesmanship tend to irritate other humanitarian workers, who typically see themselves as more respectful of the people they’re tending to. What’s more, the program implies, silencing the stomping beats of, say, the Solomon Islands in favor of pallid “Jesus Loves Me” singalongs seems just wrong.
But more disturbing than this, the documentary contends, is the psychological and spiritual danger that many progressives believe is wrought by missionaries, who swipe from indigenous people their happy, peaceful ways and stick them instead with the greed, selfishness, jealousy and wrecked natural landscapes known to be the key features of global industrial capitalism.
Despite a century of such complaints, however, Protestant missionaries persist. And they’re dogged. They dress in uncool hiking clothes and pack up uncool backpacks and buses with uncool food and uncool Bibles and venture way the heck into the jungle where they — and this is the subject of “The Tailenders” — learn thorny indigenous languages so they can actually talk with people who have never heard of America, capitalism, jihad, McWorld or Jesus Christ. Missionaries may be the most parochial and audacious avatars of our modern world.
Still, after tonight’s effort to wrestle with this paradox, you will not know for sure whether missionaries are good or bad. But you will talk about it. This gorgeous, inspired and gutsy film, the first feature documentary by Adele Horne, who also produces video art, opens up new ideological vistas on religion, technology and globalization. It dares viewers not to be surprised by it.
The focus of “The Tailenders” is the Global Recordings Network, founded in 1939 in Los Angeles by an evangelical named Joy Ridderhof. She wanted to disseminate Bible stories via phonographs and gramophones. Still photographs bring to life her adventures among those she aimed to convert; there she crouches, pale and delicate, with various less-delicate-looking figures in jungles and on beaches, marveling at a tape recorder. Of the 8,000 languages and dialects believed to exist, Global Recordings has now produced Christian propaganda in more than 5,485 of them. No linguistics department could pull this off.
The idea of releasing disembodied sound on unsuspecting people — like God in the burning bush — clearly fascinates Ms. Horne, who conveys an infectious sense of “this blows my mind.” The ingenious hand-cranked audio devices, engineered to be usable by people without electricity, are presented with the amazement that only a filmmaker pious about audiovisual technology could convey.
“Every physical movement and action reverberates throughout time and space, for good or ill,” says the spacey- and sad-sounding narrator, finding an analogy for the way sound echoes. “The ripple on the ocean’s surface caused by a gentle breeze and the deeper furrow of a ponderous slave ship are equally indelible.”
This airy poetry is anchored by down-to-earth reporting in India, Mexico and the Solomon Islands. At one point, a missionary is translating a message about Christian redemption into dialect. A native speaker finds an error. As he tells the missionary, the message now says, “We will wash away God’s sins.” Something needs to change.
Less effective than the vérité and the impressionistic voice-over are Ms. Horne’s sporadic efforts to jam her material into an interpretive framework. At the end of the film, which has presented disembodied audio as a religion unto itself, Ms. Horne seems to balk at her own originality and retreat into clichés.
The voice-over says: “Where Protestant missionaries go, industrial capitalism follows. To convert to evangelicalism is to replace indigenous collectivity with the pursuit of individual economic gain.”
And then there’s a lament for what’s lost. One of the converts says that new Protestants are shunned by their villages; they’ve forgone the religion of their parents. Only if you’ve been watching closely will you realize that that lost religion is Roman Catholicism. These congregants have not lost tribal practices, they’ve just moved on from the last wave of colonial proselytizing.


